October 24, 2008, Tasting Results

 

Site Index

About Chateau Garage
   -
Photo of the winemakers
Amateur Winemaker
   -
This year’s vintage
   -
Helpful resources/links
Winemaker Bios
   -
Marc Cohen
   -
Allan Colby
   -
Sam Grinels
   -
Carol Kelly
   -
Jim Mehl
   -
Tony Spica

Marc’s Page

How to prepare a bottle for a blind tasting
Tasting notes
Coming events
Contact us

 

 

The pond behind Chateau Garage (…yeah, right!!). Actually this was photographed by one of Chateau Garage’s wine makers at Chateau Montelena in Napa.

 

 

Results from the October 24th, 2008, Chateau Garage tasting — Grenache — held at the San Jose State/Boise State tailgate.

Some people brought incorrect wines to the tasting and therefore the results are distorted.  Some tasters rated down the imposters as not being true to type, other tasters rated them higher since they preferred the taste to Grenache. Here they are presented without further comment.

-- Marc Cohen

And thanks to Roni for his very nice Domain de Crista 2006 Cotes Du Rhone. Unfortunately we didn’t get it in time to taste and score. SG
 

Place

Score

Year

Wine

Price*

1-2

25

2005

Tablas Creek Cote de Tablas (primarily Grenache)

?

1-2

25

2007

Casillero del Diablo Cabernet Sauvignon  – Chile

?

3

32

2006

Callaway Cabernet Sauvignon

?

4

37

2004

Marques de Caceres Rioja

?

5-7

39

2002

Kilikanoan Prodigy Grenache –Australia

29.00

5-7

39

2005

d’Arenberg The Custodian Grenache – Australia

?

5-7

39

2006

Gascon Malbec – Argentina

 ?

8

49

2005

Yangarra Old Vine Grenache – Australia

  ?

* If you paticipated in the tasting and remember what you paid (and want to share that information), e-mail or call Sam with the price.

 

Copyright 1986 - 2009, Chateau Garage. All rights reserved. First use, 1986