Sept.-29-'07-Tasting Results

 

SJSU/UC Davis Site Index

 Recent Tasting Results

 

 

 

Results from the September 29th, 2007, Chateau Garage tasting — Chianti — held at the San Jose State/UC Davis tailgate.

The general consensus was that all of the wines were pretty good.  Unfortunately, not all tasters ranked all wines so the scoring is a bit skewed by having to use the next lower score for all wines not tasted for ballots that did not rate all wines.  The ranking gives a general trend and the Il Fornaio wine definitely scored above the others.  Note that the scoring was quite close below that.

-- Marc Cohen and Sam Grinels

 

Place

Score

Year

Wine

Price

1

21

2004

Il Fornaio Chianti Classico (Private Label)

29.00

2

31

2003

Fattoria Rodano Chianti Classico

17.00

3

32

2001

Querceto Chianti Classico

20.00

4

37

2004

Fattoria di Basciano Chianti Rufina

12.00

5

38

2002

Ruffino Riserva Ducale Chianti Classico

24.00

6

41

2003

Ruffino Riserva Ducale Oro Chianti Classico

28.00

7

42

2006

Aquila d’Oro Chianti

  8.00

8

49

2005

Ruffino Chianti

  9.00

 

 

Copyright 1986 - 2007, Chateau Garage. All rights reserved. First use, 1986